Leland-West Insurance

Who Do I Report My Claim To?

Automobile Insurance

You buy car insurance to pay for damage you cause to others.  Others buy it for when they cause damage to you.  When someone crashes into you and its their fault, it was once typical that you would wrestle with the at fault party's insurance company on your own.  It was normal since your own insurance company wasn't directly involved.

While the contracts for insurance have not really changed, this practice certainly has, and its only for the better for the typical consumer.  Gone are the days when your own company is not involved unless you are at fault.

What typically happens now is each party involved in an accident contacts their own insurance company directly.  The individual companies will often handle the claims adjustment and payment themselves, and settle up between themselves as well.  It makes for a much more service-oriented and consumer-friendly process.

What typically (but not always) happens with respect to repairing your vehicle is as follows.  Lets assume a fender-bender accident with no injuries:

  • You are rear-ended while stopped at an intersection and your car is heavily damaged.  The police cite the other driver.  You are pretty sore from the impact and are taken from the scene to the hospital in an ambulance as a precaution.  You spend a couple of hours in the emergency room getting checked out, and are released.
  • You report the accident to your insurance company.  Your insurance company immediately issues you a rental car.
  • Your own insurance company sends an adjustor out to the tow yard to assess the vehicle damage.  Its not a total loss and the vehicle can be repaired.
  • You get your car into the shop (of your choice, hopefully) for repair
  • Your own insurance company waives your collision deductible since the accident is not your fault (this is not always true).
  • After a few weeks the repair is complete.  You take your car home.
  • Your insurance company hands the bill for all of the above to the other driver's insurance company, who reimburses them directly (this process is known as subrogation).

Strictly speaking, as far as you the consumer are concerned the process is the same whether you deal with one company or the other.  In actual practice it is far easier for you to deal with your own company, who has a vested interest in providing you with good service, than it is ever going to be dealing with another company you have no ties to.  Also, you can pretty well expect that when it comes to properly fixing your car, an insurance company is going to be far better at beating the money out of another insurance company than you are.  And they'll do it for free.

This is all a big win for the consumer, but unfortunately it can't all be roses.  What if you are injured?  well, up to a point you can still expect your own insurance company to handle the matter.  Typically they can do this up to the limit of your Medical Payments or Personal Injury Protection coverage.  If however your injuries are more extensive, then your own company - who, lets not forget, is not necessarily obligated to pay for any of this - will likely hand off to the other driver's carrier to pay out of the other driver's Bodily Injury Liability coverage.

But if its a simple accident with vehicle damage only, chances are you can make your life easier during a difficult time by simply reporting your accident to your own insurance company and dealing with them directly.

Matt Robertson's small picture
Article by
Matt Robertson
Matt is the Managing Partner at Leland-West Insurance Brokers, Inc. He started with the firm while still a college student, way back in 1984. According to Matt his only remaining hobby is Motorsport ... because its all he can afford ("will work for tires"). Reach him at matt@lelandwest.com